Have you ever had a
Blind Date with a Cookie?
A playful mystery treat experience packed in sealed envelopes, plus artisanal freshly baked cookies, breads, cinnamon rolls & gluten-friendly options!
Blind Date with a Cookie • Pop-Up Drops
“I can do all things through Christ which strengtheneth me.”
Swipe for Your Cookie Match
Swipe right to match, swipe left to pass, or browse candidate profiles!
How Cookie Dating Works
Ready for your next mystery date?
Blind Date Envelope #101
Downtown Appleton • Sealed Mystery Flavor
- •I'm sweet & nostalgic.
- •I believe the best memories are made around the kitchen table.
- •I'm layered with warmth & impossible to forget.
Someone who loves the classics & knows that homemade is always better.
- •Will convince you to stay in instead of going out.
- •Thinks dessert counts as dinner.
Meet Your Match In Person
Saturdays (8:00 AM – 12:30 PM)
Members earn sweet points on every blind date match & get first pick of surprise flavors!
Fresh Bakes & Sweet Treats
Cookies, celebration cakes, cupcakes, French macarons, home-baked pies, and artisan breads from Sugar on the Shelf.
SignatureBlind Date & Artisan Cookies
Fresh drop cookies and mystery Blind Date profile packages available weekly at the market.
Blind Date Info →
Party FavoriteGiant Cookie Cakes
Giant home-baked cookie cakes customized with rich piped buttercream for any milestone.
Order Cookie Cakes →
Fresh Hearth LoavesFresh Artisan Breads
Scratch-made golden hearth loaves baked with wholesome, quality ingredients.
View Breads →
Warm & IcedCinnamon Rolls
Mouth-watering, fluffy cinnamon rolls topped with sweet luscious icing.
Order Cinnamon Rolls →
Gluten-FriendlyGluten-Friendly Options
Delicious gluten-friendly cookies and cinnamon rolls so everyone can enjoy something sweet!
Order GF Treats →Party PacksCelebration Cookie Platters
Custom cookie boxes, giant cookie cakes, and party platters for graduations and birthdays.
Celebration Details →Hosting a graduation party? A birthday bash? An anniversary celebration?
No matter the occasion, our giant decorated cookie cakes and celebration cookie platters are the perfect dessert! Delicious, fun, and easy to share – everyone loves them!
Nikole • Sugar on the Shelf
“Homemade with love, baked with faith.”
Hi! I’m Nikole—mom to two girls, small-batch baker, and lover of Jesus with my whole heart. Sugar on the Shelf is a woman-owned, faith-based bakery created to bring joyful home-baked treats, celebration sweets, and our signature Blind Date with a Cookie to the Fox Valley community.
Downtown Appleton Farmers Market
Find our Sugar on the Shelf booth on College Avenue in Downtown Appleton with all your favorite cookies, Blind Date cookies, cupcakes, and bakery items!
Downtown Appleton Farmers Market & Pop-Up Booth